Reviews

Assassin’s Creed Shadows Review – Can Ubisoft save itself?

Alright, fellow gamers, we need to talk about Assassin’s Creed Shadows. I’ve sunk a serious amount of time into this one – we’re talking late nights, energy drinks, and maybe a few too many missed meals. So, trust me when I say I’ve got a pretty good handle on what this game brings to the table. Forget the corporate speak and the overly formal reviews; this is coming straight from a player who’s been in the trenches, mastering the blades of Naoe and the brute force of Yasuke.

assassin's creed shadows

First Impressions: Setting the Stage

From the moment the game boots up, you’re hit with the stunning visuals of feudal Japan. Seriously, Ubisoft has outdone themselves with the sheer beauty and detail of this world. We’re not just talking pretty landscapes; it feels alive. The bustling towns, the serene forests, the imposing castles – every location has its own distinct vibe. And the seasonal changes? Absolutely breathtaking. Watching the leaves turn crimson in autumn or the snow blanket the rooftops in winter isn’t just a visual gimmick; it genuinely impacts the gameplay and atmosphere.

The Dynamic Duo: Naoe and Yasuke

Let’s get straight to the heart of the gameplay: the two playable characters, Naoe and Yasuke. This dual protagonist system is arguably the most innovative aspect of Shadows, and it completely changes how you approach the game.

Naoe: The Shadow Dancer

Playing as Naoe feels like classic Assassin’s Creed, but with a refined edge. She’s all about stealth, agility, and striking from the shadows. Her movement is fluid and responsive, making parkour and infiltration a genuine joy. The toolset at her disposal – grappling hooks, smoke bombs, and an array of deadly ninja gadgets – allows for incredibly creative approaches to missions. I found myself constantly experimenting with different tactics, trying to ghost through enemy encampments without ever being seen. The stealth mechanics here are genuinely the best we’ve seen in a while. The enemy AI feels smarter, forcing you to be more strategic in your movements and use of cover.

Naoe

Yasuke: The Unstoppable Force

Then there’s Yasuke, the legendary samurai. Playing as him is a completely different experience. Forget sneaking around; Yasuke is a force of nature. His combat is brutal and impactful. Wielding his katana feels weighty and powerful, and engaging in direct confrontations is a viable (and often satisfying) option. While he might not be as nimble as Naoe when it comes to traversal, his sheer strength allows him to overcome obstacles in his own way. Breaking through barricades and taking down heavily armored enemies feels incredibly empowering.

Yasuke

Forced Diversity or Brilliant Design?

Now, there’s been some talk about whether the distinct playstyles feel forced. Honestly, while there are moments where the game nudges you towards a specific character for a particular mission, I never felt like it was overly restrictive. In fact, I often found myself switching between the two to tackle objectives in the most efficient or enjoyable way. Sometimes, a stealthy approach with Naoe is perfect for scouting and taking out key targets, while switching to Yasuke for the final assault can be incredibly satisfying. The contrast between their playstyles keeps the gameplay fresh and engaging throughout the lengthy campaign.

Story and Characters: A Tale of Two Paths

The narrative in Shadows weaves together the stories of Naoe and Yasuke, both driven by their own motivations and caught up in the tumultuous events of the Sengoku period. While the overarching plot is engaging enough to keep you invested, I have to admit that the characters themselves didn’t quite grab me as much as some of the previous protagonists in the series.  

Assassin's Creed Shadows Story

A Missed Connection?

Don’t get me wrong, both Naoe and Yasuke have their moments, and their individual storylines are interesting. However, their interactions felt a little… distant at times. Perhaps it’s the cultural barrier or the way their stories are structured, but I didn’t quite feel the same level of emotional connection to them as I did with, say, Ezio or Kassandra. The supporting cast is a mixed bag, with some memorable figures and others who fade into the background. The dialogue, while functional, occasionally dips into the realm of being a bit cheesy, which can take you out of the immersion.

Exploring Feudal Japan: A Living, Breathing World

The true star of Assassin’s Creed Shadows is undoubtedly its meticulously crafted world. From the sprawling castles to the serene bamboo forests and the bustling market towns, every location is brimming with detail and atmosphere. The environmental storytelling is top-notch, with hidden details and secrets rewarding exploration.

Feudal Japan

Verticality and Exploration

The level design encourages both horizontal and vertical exploration. Naoe’s agility makes scaling rooftops and navigating tight alleyways a breeze, while Yasuke’s strength allows him to find alternative routes and hidden passages. The world feels vast and interconnected, with a satisfying sense of discovery every time you venture off the beaten path.

Side Activities and Distractions

Beyond the main story missions, there’s a wealth of side activities to keep you occupied. From helping out villagers to hunting down rare animals and uncovering hidden shrines, there’s always something to do. While some of these side quests can feel a bit repetitive, many offer unique insights into the world and its inhabitants, adding depth to the overall experience.  

Combat and Progression: Honing Your Skills

The combat system in Shadows is a noticeable step up from previous titles. While it retains the core mechanics of parrying, dodging, and attacking, it feels more fluid and responsive. Both Naoe and Yasuke have their own distinct combat styles and skill trees, allowing you to customize their abilities to suit your preferred playstyle.  

Combat System

Mastering the Blade

Naoe’s combat is fast and focused on precision strikes and utilizing her ninja tools to gain an advantage. Yasuke’s combat, on the other hand, is more about raw power and overwhelming your opponents with heavy attacks. Mastering the nuances of each character’s combat style is crucial for survival, especially on higher difficulty settings.  

The Knowledge Rank Grind

The progression system, while generally well-designed, does have one aspect that felt a bit tedious: the “knowledge ranks.” These are required to unlock certain higher-tier skills and are primarily earned by completing exploration tasks. While exploring the world is enjoyable, the specific tasks required to gain knowledge ranks sometimes felt like busywork, breaking the flow of the main story.

You might also like this: Monster Hunter Review

Visuals and Performance: A Feast for the Eyes

As I mentioned earlier, Assassin’s Creed Shadows is a visually stunning game. The level of detail in the environments, character models, and animations is truly impressive. The lighting and weather effects further enhance the atmosphere, creating a truly immersive experience.

Running Smoothly?

Performance-wise, I played the game on a high-end PC, and for the most part, it ran incredibly smoothly. I did encounter a few minor graphical glitches here and there, but nothing game-breaking. Ubisoft has clearly put a lot of effort into optimizing the game, and it shows.

Length and Replayability: A Long Journey

Assassin’s Creed Shadows is a massive game. My initial playthrough clocked in at well over 80 hours, and I still feel like there’s plenty more to explore and discover. The dual protagonist system adds a layer of replayability, as playing through the game with the other character offers a significantly different experience. However, I can see how some players might feel a bit burnt out by the sheer length of the game, especially if they find some of the side activities repetitive.

Is Assassin’s Creed Shadows a Must-Play?

Alright, let’s cut to the chase. After all those hours, the question you really want answered is: should you spend your hard-earned cash and precious gaming time on Assassin’s Creed Shadows? From my perspective as someone who’s seen their fair share of open-world epics and stealth-action titles, here’s my honest rating:

8.3 out of 10

Here’s the breakdown of why I landed on that score:

The High Points:

  • The Dual Protagonist System (9/10): This is genuinely innovative and keeps the gameplay incredibly fresh. Switching between Naoe and Yasuke offers two distinct and engaging playstyles that complement each other brilliantly.
  • The Stunning World of Feudal Japan (9.5/10): Ubisoft has absolutely nailed the atmosphere and detail of this setting. It’s a joy to explore, and the seasonal changes are a fantastic touch.
  • Refined Stealth Mechanics (8.5/10): For fans of classic Assassin’s Creed, Naoe’s gameplay will feel like a welcome return to form, with some smart modern improvements.
  • Engaging and Impactful Combat (8/10): Both characters offer satisfying combat experiences, with their own unique strengths and weaknesses.
  • Impressive Visuals and Performance (8/10): The game is a visual treat, and it runs surprisingly well, allowing you to truly immerse yourself in the world.

The Areas for Improvement:

  • The Story and Characters (7/10): While the overarching narrative is decent, the characters themselves didn’t leave a lasting impression, and the dialogue could be a bit clunky at times.
  • Repetitive Elements in Progression (7.5/10): The “knowledge rank” system, while encouraging exploration, occasionally felt like a bit of a grind and could disrupt the flow of the main story.
Assassin's Creed Shadows Rating

Overall:

Assassin’s Creed Shadows is a strong entry in the franchise that brings some genuinely exciting new elements to the table, particularly the dual protagonist system and the breathtaking setting. While it might not reach the heights of some of the absolute classics in the series due to some shortcomings in the narrative and progression, it offers a lengthy, engaging, and visually stunning experience that’s well worth your time. If you’re a fan of open-world games, stealth action, or simply fascinated by feudal Japan, then you’ll likely find a lot to love in Assassin’s Creed Shadows. It’s a solid recommendation from this seasoned gamer.

Amir Ljv

Devoted journalist and game developer with a strong passion for video games from past, present, and future. Lifelong gamer with high-level gaming skills and industry knowledge, Able to work independently and effectively as a team member.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button