Benny is the first real boss in Vampire The Masquerade Bloodlines 2. You’re probably staring at the screen now, totally stuck on what to do next with the Vampire the masquerade bloodlines 2 benny choice.
It feels like a massive decision: Hand the rogue Sheriff Benny over to Katsumi and the Anarchs (who are pissed he’s been killing thin bloods) or give him back to Ryong and The Court (his boss, the Prince of Seattle). Also don’t forget to check out our Vampire the Masquerade Bloodlines 2 endings guide.
I was stuck here too, agonizing over the right choice. Here’s the breakdown of what actually happens.
What happens if you give Benny to Katsumi (Anarchs)?
Siding with the Anarchs? If you give Benny to Katsumi, she’ll be grateful and tell you to visit the “Hole in the Wall” later.
When you get back to Weaver Tower, Ryong will be visibly unhappy with your decision. But here’s the thing: you can pretty much explain it away, and she still appoints you as the new Sheriff of the Court.
The main takeaway is you’re now in better standing with the Anarchs, which will likely help you later in the game.
What happens if you give Benny to Ryong (The Court)?
Want to play nice with the Prince? If you deny Katsumi and hand Benny over to Ryong (The Court), Katsumi will let you walk away without a fight.
When you return to Ryong, she’ll be pleased, you’ll be in her good graces, and… she still appoints you as the new Sheriff of the Court.
This path locks in your better standing with The Court.
Does the Benny choice actually matter in Bloodlines 2?
Here’s the real talk: in the short term, not really.
No matter who you give Benny to, he disappears from the story for the rest of the campaign. The next main story beats play out largely the same, and you become Sheriff either way. You can’t fail this mission.
The only real difference is your faction loyalty. This decision is the first major step in deciding whether you’re leaning toward the Anarchs or The Court. While it doesn’t change the next 10 hours of gameplay, this choice will likely stack up with other decisions to play a role in what ending you get.
While this decision affects your faction standing, other choices in the game can lead to different kinds of relationships. If you’re wondering who you can romance, we have a full Bloodlines 2 romance guide that breaks it all down.
My Verdict: Don’t sweat it. There is no wrong answer here. The immediate consequences are almost identical. Just pick the faction you vibe with more.
Vampire The Masquerade Bloodlines 2 Steam Page
Thanks for staying with Game.Dazepuzzle
